United States · New York limitation periods
How does New York’s cancer-malpractice timing compare discovery and treatment?
CPLR 214-a compares qualifying cancer knowledge with last continuous treatment. Its knowledge branch includes a seven-year qualification, so one date is insufficient.
- Period
- 30-month alternatives with the statutory seven-year qualification
- Trigger
- Negligent act, qualifying knowledge and last continuous treatment
- Rule
- CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii)
Current official statutory text reviewed. A displayed Senate revision date is not an amendment effective date.
Source guide · No automated date
How does New York’s cancer-malpractice timing compare discovery and treatment?
The preset accepts one date but this cancer provision compares knowledge and continuous treatment with a distinct act-based qualification. It cannot select the governing result.
CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii)What lawyers say
5.0“The platform is really easy to use.”
Michael B.Employment litigation attorney · California
“The Evidence Record saved us time with our insurance on bankruptcy matters.”
MariaBankruptcy and commercial attorney · London, UK
“The most up-to-date service we could find.”
Li ChenArbitration practitioner · Singapore
Which event controls this CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii) inquiry?
Identify alleged negligent failure to diagnose cancer or a malignant tumor, rather than applying this branch to every late medical diagnosis.
The knowledge event requires actual or reasonable knowledge of the negligent act or omission and its causation of injury.
The text selects the later of that knowledge branch and last continuous treatment for the relevant condition. The seven-year proviso appears in branch (i), not as an unqualified cap on every section 214-a action.
Public-defendant cancer timing also has section 203(g)(2). Separate claim-notice and commencement acts require their own provisions.
CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii)Which periods must be established before counting?
- Identify alleged negligent failure to diagnose cancer or a malignant tumor, rather than applying this branch to every late medical diagnosis.
- The knowledge event requires actual or reasonable knowledge of the negligent act or omission and its causation of injury.
- The text selects the later of that knowledge branch and last continuous treatment for the relevant condition. The seven-year proviso appears in branch (i), not as an unqualified cap on every section 214-a action.
- Public-defendant cancer timing also has section 203(g)(2). Separate claim-notice and commencement acts require their own provisions.
- This guide supplies no fixed date. Establish the applicable statutory branches and their actual events before applying any calendar-month, calendar-year or final-day provision.
- Preserve the alleged negligent act, both knowledge findings, qualifying continuous treatment and the separately compared statutory boundaries.
A calendar anniversary cannot decide the statutory classification or supply missing facts. No computed or paid date is published.
CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii)What distinguishes the relevant statutory branches?
Fictitious comparison. Two patients know of the same alleged diagnostic failure. Only one has qualifying continuous treatment for that same condition. The common knowledge event cannot establish an identical controlling period.
The preset accepts one date but this cancer provision compares knowledge and continuous treatment with a distinct act-based qualification. It cannot select the governing result.
Which qualifications change this inquiry?
- Two knowledge requirements
- Preserve when the claimant knew or reasonably should have known both negligence and resulting injury.
- Treatment alternative
- Do not silently cap the separately stated last-treatment alternative by treating branch (i)’s proviso as universal.
- Public-defendant cross-reference
- Section 203(g)(2) addresses listed public-claim laws and their cancer event rules.
- Historical executive-order toll
- The calculators accept selected events after November 3, 2020. They do not apply the 2020 executive-order toll. Brash distinguishes a toll from a suspension. Historical events require separate review and receive no calculated or paid date here. Do not add 228 days to every historical event without testing its actual applicability.
- Preserve the applicable edition and establish the actual statutory facts independently.
- The preset accepts one date but this cancer provision compares knowledge and continuous treatment with a distinct act-based qualification. It cannot select the governing result.
Which facts and completed acts should be preserved?
Questions about CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii)
How does New York’s cancer-malpractice timing compare discovery and treatment?
Is a cancer diagnosis alone the knowledge event?
No. The text requires knowledge of the alleged negligence and that it caused injury.
CPLR 214-AIs seven years a universal medical-malpractice long-stop?
The proviso is situated in the cancer knowledge branch. This guide does not recast it as a universal cap.
CPLR 214-ADoes this page compute the controlling date?
No. The actual negligence, knowledge, treatment and applicable public-claim conditions require separate review.
CPLR 214-AOfficial New York sources and review
Provisions used (11)
| Provision | Purpose |
|---|---|
| CPLR 214-a, cancer clauses (i) and (ii) | The particular statutory procedure and its conditions |
| CPLR 203(a), (c) | The separately identified qualification or accrual provision |
| CPLR 202 | The separately identified qualification or accrual provision |
| Brash v Richards, 195 AD3d 582 (2d Dept 2021) | Historical tolling and the calculator’s scope boundary |
| General Construction Law 20 | Applicable event-day, calendar-interval or statutory final-day provision |
| General Construction Law 30 | Applicable event-day, calendar-interval or statutory final-day provision |
| General Construction Law 58 | Applicable event-day, calendar-interval or statutory final-day provision |
| General Construction Law 24 | Applicable event-day, calendar-interval or statutory final-day provision |
| General Construction Law 25-a | Applicable event-day, calendar-interval or statutory final-day provision |
| CPLR 304 | Commencement by filing, separate from defendant service |
| 22 NYCRR 202.5-b(d)(3)(i), (f)(1) | Recorded transmission and required fee information in the applicable NYSCEF program; initiating filing does not itself serve a defendant |